The Denver Broncos are hosting two very different quarterbacks for tryouts during their rookie minicamp this week.

The first is E.J. Warner, a 22-year-old prospect coming out of Fresno State. The second player is Nathan Peterman, a 32-year-old veteran who has played for five different NFL teams throughout his career.

However, Peterman’s name isn't being taken in enthusiastically by the Broncos fans. 

The reason? Well, he didn't really have a great time in the NFL.

One of the most memorable moments for all the fans was his game as a Buffalo Bills player against the Los Angeles Chargers in 2017. He completed only 6 out of 14 passes for 66 yards. 

The biggest issue was that while he didn't throw any touchdowns, he threw five interceptions in the first half. Because of these mistakes, the Bills lost the game 54–24, and the coach replaced him with Tyrod Taylor at halftime. 

Following his time with the Bills, he moved across various teams, like the Raiders and the Chicago Bears. His latest stint was with the Atlanta Falcons’ practice squad in 2024.

Over the course of his NFL career, Peterman has recorded 712 passing yards and scored only four touchdowns while throwing 13 interceptions.

His career statistics reflect the uphill battle he has faced, with a completion percentage of 53.1% and a quarterback rating of 39.4. 

Now, because he spent the 2025 season out of football, he is eligible to participate in this week’s rookie minicamp as he seeks a fresh start in Denver as their QB prospect.

However, the fans are both quite shocked and disappointed with the decision, as they let their voices be heard on social media.

Fans React to Nathan Peterman Trying Out at the Denver Broncos Rookie Minicamp

The Denver Broncos’ decision to invite veteran quarterback Nathan Peterman to their rookie minicamp has sparked disbelief across the NFL landscape.

The move has been described as statistically puzzling by fans, per Broncos Wire.

The first comment read, “Why? Absolutely pointless.” 

While head coach Sean Payton is known for his thorough evaluation of quarterbacks, his recent decision was met with heavy skepticism regarding this specific addition.  

Peterman’s reputation for turnovers continues to precede him, leading another fan to joke, “Are we back to practicing interceptions?”

For many, his reappearance was simply a shock to the system: “That’s a name I haven’t heard in a minute,” read another comment.

Fan skepticism was perhaps best captured when one supporter suggested a return to a 2020 cult hero.

“I'd rather bring Kendall Hinton back to play QB.” This refers to the wide receiver who famously stepped in as Denver’s emergency quarterback during a COVID-19 roster crisis. 

Ultimately, while the team likely views Peterman as a "camp arm" to facilitate drills, fans aren't buying the utility signing.

As one critic summarized, “Why out of all people I get it’s just have a camp arm but d*** talk about bottom of the barrel.” 

The comments by fans indicate disappointment. Many fans expressed that the signing did not align with the franchise's future-focused direction.

Read more at the Denver Broncos Community!

Written by

Aaindri Thakuri

Edited by

Kalp Thaker